1. Bird on the Roof
4.5(1 rating)
47 S Elmwood Ave
Espresso martini
“Not to sweet good amount of foam added cinnamon”— Nick Holahan, 4.5, Nov 8, 2026
- Cocktail Bar
- Brunch
Best Espresso Martinis in Montauk, New York
2 bars ranked by 2 ratings from people who actually ordered the drink. Scores are for the espresso martini only. How it works
2 rated spots in Montauk
2. Harvest on Fort Pond
3.5(1 rating)
11 S Emery St$$$
Espresso martini
“Super foamy not sweet at all”— Nick Holahan, 3.5, Nov 7, 2026
- Seafood
Espresso martinis in Montauk: FAQ
- What is the best espresso martini in Montauk?
- Right now Bird on the Roof (4.5/5 from 1 rating), and Harvest on Fort Pond (3.5/5 from 1 rating) lead the Montauk ranking. Rankings update hourly as EspressoMyTini members rate drinks in the app.
- Where do these ratings come from?
- Every rating is submitted through the EspressoMyTini iOS app by a signed-in member who ordered the drink. Each rating scores the espresso martini itself on foam, sweetness balance and presentation. Venues cannot pay for placement.
Nearby cities
Know a better espresso martini in Montauk?
Ratings on this page come only from the app. Rate a spot and it shows up here within the hour.